top of page

A job application rejection hurts, but it might not be about you

  • Writer: Penny Langstaff
    Penny Langstaff
  • Sep 4, 2024
  • 2 min read

Updated: Feb 12


Rejected wording on photo of emails coming out of laptop reflecting how tough the job market is in NZ

If you’ve applied for a role you felt confident about and then receive a rejection with no explanation, it’s completely natural to feel frustrated and confused. While the reason may relate to something in your CV, cover letter, or overall application, it’s also possible the decision had nothing to do with you at all. Sometimes a job application rejection is because of internal factors on the employer’s side—things you simply can’t control. Here are just a few possible reasons.


The job advert doesn't accurately reflect the role

Even if the job advert suggests that your skills and experience are a strong match, the description itself may not be entirely accurate. This could be down to a poorly written advert or a hiring manager failing to provide the recruiter or hiring team with a clear, detailed brief.


The company changes it's mind following an interview process

Often a hiring manager will request a new staff member, but after meeting several candidates, they realize the role needs something different. They may decide the current team can absorb the workload, or they may redistribute responsibilities internally, opening the door to a completely different type of candidate than originally planned.

An internal candidate or internally referred candidate applies

This is a common scenario and unfortunately often happens once the external recruitment process is underway. If the company isn't required to compare internal and external applicants (see the next point), they'll usually prioritise the internal or referred candidate and simply withdraw the externally advertised vacancy.

An internal candidate is earmarked for the job but company policy requires an external advertising process

In some cases, an organisation has already identified an internal employee for a vacancy, but company policy requires the position to be advertised externally. The job ad is often posted for a shorter period than usual, and while the company may interview one or two external candidates, the likelihood of choosing anyone other than the internal applicant are extremely low.

You don't "fit" the team or company culture

Your skills and experience might be a perfect match for the role, but you still might not be the right fit for the team or the organisation's culture. While you can sometimes pick up clues from the job ad (social, fun, dynamic, corporate, professional) or from their website (values, projects, people, culture), it's almost impossible to know the exact personality or working style they have in mind.

Your salary expectation is outside the company's budget Even after researching typical salaries for the role, there may still be a gap between what you expect and what the employer is prepared to offer. You might get the chance to reconsider your expectations, but in a competitive market with many applicants and limited vacancies, organisations often move forward with candidates whose salary requirements fit comfortably within their budget

Budget cuts / financial constraints / change in business strategy When a company encounters financial challenges or shifts its business strategy, recruitment is often one of the first areas impacted. Unfortunately, these changes can occur mid‑process, resulting in the vacancy being closed altogether.

So if you’re applying for roles and getting little or no feedback, remember that even with a strong, well‑crafted application, there are many reasons for an unsuccessful outcome that are completely outside your control.

Comments


Auckland, New Zealand

Monday to Friday 8am-6pm

Short notice and weekend appointments possible.  Call or email me to discuss

Follow on social media for tips, updates and new blogs

Personalised Coaching Services New Zealand wide

bottom of page